No Other Granola Recipe Compares to This One (2024)

Kitchn Love Letters

facebook

pinterest

email

comments

We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.

No Other Granola Recipe Compares to This One (1)

There isn’t much going on in my life right now, as I practice self-quarantine, so I spend my time hanging out by the oven, stirring olive oil, maple syrup, and brown sugar-coated rolled oats and nuts at 10-minute intervals until they’ve reached the desired level of toastiness. Then, I stage a photoshoot in my parents’ kitchen. Yes, quarantine has turned me into the kind of person who takes photos of my granola in Portrait Mode. Let me live.

My newly formed homemade granola habit was born out of a discussion that took place at my family’s breakfast table in New Jersey. We were joking about the sheer versatility of rolled oats — overnight oats, savory oats, flour, muffins, breads, cookies, milk — trying to one-up each other with unmentioned uses of the pantry staple. (After six weeks together, it’s clear that we might be running out of things to talk about.) Come lunchtime, I was inspired to turn our rolled oats into granola — and not just any granola.

Months ago, one of my roommates in the city had dinner at Eleven Madison Park, one of the fanciest restaurants in New York City. She generously let me taste test the contents of the Mason jar of homemade granola that she (and everyone who dines at EMP) got to take home at the end of the meal. I’d never tasted any granola like it. It was markedly saltier than any store-bought granola I’d ever tried, which perfectly balanced the clusters of oats bound together with a soul-warming sugary glaze. I knew chances of ever securing my own jar were slim to none, since I didn’t (and don’t) have $600 to spend on a tasting and an accompanying wine pairing, so I scoured the internet for a recipe to recreate it.

I followed the NYT Cooking recipe, which happens to be fairly quarantine pantry- and budget-friendly. Who would have thought, coming from a restaurant that serves dishes like Brook Trout Cured with Radish, Sesame, & Smoked Roe and Crab with Sorrel and Amaranth? Blessedly, this recipe only called for rolled oats, shelled pistachios, unsweetened coconut flakes, pumpkin seeds, salt, light brown sugar, maple syrup, EVOO, and dried cherries.(I swapped in pecans for pistachios because that’s what we had.) Assembling the mixture took me less than 10 minutes. I then placed it in the oven in an even layer, and soon enough my parents’ house started to smell like a bed and breakfast.

Once finished and cooled, as is the ritual, I decant the granola into two empty tea tins and my family picks at it throughout the week, sprinkling it over yogurt (or just straight into our mouths) for however long it lasts. It’s a precious commodity, as we’ve started to run low on rolled oats and dried cherries, and we’re fresh out of coconut and maple syrup. So far, I’ve made this recipe every Sunday we’ve been in quarantine.

What I love most about this recipe is that it’s kind of a funny contradiction. Yes, it technically was born out of the kitchen of one of the fanciest restaurants in the world, but I had everything I needed to make a batch right at home in my very normal parents’ very normal pantry. And even if I didn’t have all the ingredients called for, the recipe leaves room for ample tweaks. Swap quick oats for rolled oats, dried cranberries for cherries, shredded coconut for coconut flakes, dark brown for light brown sugar, and any nut for the pistachios. The formula is foolproof — I promise.

Like me, you’ll learn quickly that the fanciest granola in the world isn’t all that fancy. The magic is simply that it’s a treat meant to be shared. And as long as this granola makes Sundays while sheltering-in-place feel even a little bit special, I’ll be making a big ol’ batch.

This story is part of ourStaying Homeseries, in which Kitchn editors and contributors share the recipes, tools, and habits that are helping them through the pandemic. As we work to flatten the curve, we’re cooking more, shopping less frequently, and looking for the good and the bright as much as we can.In this very disorienting time, here’s what’s keeping us going.

No Other Granola Recipe Compares to This One (2024)

FAQs

Why are homemade granola not crunchy? ›

Until I ran into a clever trick, courtesy of Julia Turshen's new cookbook Simply Julia for getting granola as crispy as you want it: add egg whites. Per Turshen, for every three cups of rolled oats you want to transform into granola, add a ¼ cup each maple syrup and olive oil.

Why is homemade granola better? ›

Advantage homemade. Both granolas have whole oats as their main ingredient, but the Kellogg's is high in refined sugar and contains palm oil. The homemade version contains protein-rich pecans and uses only a small amount of honey, brown sugar, and vegetable oil. It took me an hour to make granola from scratch.

Is granola cheaper to make? ›

It can definitely be cheaper, especially if you can buy the ingredients in bulk, like I do,” she explains. “Rolled oats are cheap, and you can get nuts and seeds and butters from Costco.”

How do you keep homemade granola crispy? ›

Whether it's homemade or store-bought, properly storing granola will help extend the shelf life and maintain crunchiness. Store granola in an airtight container or tightly sealed zip-top bag in a dry, dark place away from heat.

What ingredients should you avoid in granola? ›

Check the ingredient list, avoiding products that list sugar or sweeteners —including natural sweeteners like honey — within the first few ingredients. Instead, the first few ingredients should be whole foods, such as oats, nuts, seeds, and dried fruit. You may also want to look for varieties high in protein and fiber.

How do you make granola taste better? ›

Dried cranberries – For a pop of sweetness and yummy chewy texture! I'm a cranberry fan, but goji berries, raisins, chopped dried apricots, dried currants, tart cherries, and blueberries would all be great. And if you prefer your granola without dried fruit, go ahead and skip it!

Why is my homemade granola soft? ›

I aim to let it hit room temperature, whatever that may be; the real point is to give it ample time to shed excess heat and steam. This should take about 45 minutes; if left out indefinitely, the granola can turn sticky or soft, so do try to put it away as soon after cooling as you can.

Why is my granola chewy? ›

1. Baking time: Increase the baking time for your granola. The longer you bake it, the drier and crunchier it will become. Keep a close eye on it to avoid burning, and stir it occasionally during baking to ensure even toasting.

What was the downside to granola as a food? ›

On the downside, granola can be high in added sugars, hidden calories, and saturated fat, making some options less healthy. Choosing the right type of granola, controlling serving sizes, and homemade options can make granola a part of a healthy diet.

What is better than granola? ›

Muesli is a better choice for people looking for low-sugar cereals or people with diabetes. Both are healthy, but consider granola if you want your cereal with a dash of sweetness from honey, chocolate or maple syrup.

What is healthier than granola? ›

Since muesli and granola are made from the same ingredients, their nutritional value is pretty much the same. Without anything added to it, muesli is healthier than granola in the sense that it has less fat and sugar.

Is it OK to eat granola every day? ›

The Bottom Line

Granola is healthy in small amounts, especially because oats, nuts, seeds and dried fruit in granola provide some fiber that's good for heart and gut health. However, granola can also be a rich source of calories, saturated fat and sugar, depending on the brand you buy.

What does eating a lot of granola do? ›

High-fiber foods, like the oats and whole grains found in granola, fill you up and keep you feeling fuller longer. Dietary studies have found eating a high-fiber diet can help you lose weight. Dried fruit and nuts also contain antioxidants, like vitamin E, which can lower inflammation in the body.

Does homemade granola get crunchy as it cools? ›

Your homemade granola will continue to crisp up as it cools. It's tempting to start eating it as soon as it comes out of the oven, but if you let it rest for 15 minutes on the sheet pan, it'll be extra crisp and toasty – totally worth the wait!

Why is my homemade granola dry? ›

Keep in mind that the granola won't be dry right out of the oven — it will dry as it cools. So take it out of the oven when it looks lightly toasted and smells like cooked honey. We're going for a toasty smell here. Add dried fruit after baking.

Why is my granola bar not crunchy? ›

For really crispy bars, you can either bake them all the way to 32 or more minutes or you can take the bars out after 25 minutes, let them cool for a bit, slice them up into the bars, and then put them back in on a baking sheet to bake for 10 -15 minutes so that they get more crispy.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Patricia Veum II

Last Updated:

Views: 5722

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Patricia Veum II

Birthday: 1994-12-16

Address: 2064 Little Summit, Goldieton, MS 97651-0862

Phone: +6873952696715

Job: Principal Officer

Hobby: Rafting, Cabaret, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Inline skating, Magic, Graffiti

Introduction: My name is Patricia Veum II, I am a vast, combative, smiling, famous, inexpensive, zealous, sparkling person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.